Court Upholds Gemini's $5 Million CFTC Settlement
A federal judge rejected a joint request from Gemini and the CFTC to overturn a January 2025 settlement, leaving the $5 million penalty and compliance terms in place.

A federal judge ruled on Thursday, October 15, that Gemini and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission cannot reverse their January 2025 settlement. US District Judge Alvin Hellerstein denied their joint motion to vacate the agreement, leaving the court's original judgment fully in effect.
Judge Hellerstein found the arguments presented did not meet the legal standard for reopening the case. He stated Gemini had litigated against the CFTC for more than three years before settling. The agency's current view of the case does not require vacating the settlement, he ruled. This decision reinforces that courts retain control of their judgments, even when a regulatory agency changes its enforcement approach. Washington's stance on cryptocurrency may have shifted, but previously approved settlements remain binding.
The CFTC joined Gemini in seeking to overturn the settlement after an internal review of its digital asset priorities. The CFTC has said "it never should have brought the case against Gemini." The judge ruled the CFTC's reconsideration could not undo the settlement and that Gemini had not been coerced into agreeing to the deal. In the immediate term, very little changes for Gemini; the settlement stays in force and the court imposed no new fine.
Origins of the 2017 allegations
The settlement stemmed from a 2022 CFTC lawsuit alleging Gemini misled regulators in 2017. This occurred during a review of Gemini's proposed bitcoin futures contract. The regulator accused the exchange of providing false information, including on the susceptibility of bitcoin futures to manipulation.
The consent order detailed specific allegations. The CFTC alleged Gemini failed to disclose that certain customers traded using borrowed funds. It alleged self-trading occurred despite safeguards and that some traders received special fee arrangements. Gemini was accused of submitting trading volume information without disclosing this borrowed fund activity or the special fee deals. Gemini and the CFTC later argued the 2022 complaint would not have been filed under different administration priorities and claimed the regulator used "inappropriate tactics."
Settlement terms and financials
The January 2025 consent judgment required Gemini to pay a $5 million penalty and accept a permanent injunction. The key terms of the settlement are as follows:
Gemini had already paid the $5 million penalty prior to the October ruling. The settlement was reached during the Biden administration, before the Trump administration took office and launched a friendlier approach to the crypto industry. The ruling means Gemini must continue to adhere to a court order prohibiting it from publicly rejecting the settlement’s findings.
Gemini’s recent strategic shifts
Amid this ongoing legal chapter, Gemini has undertaken significant operational changes. In February, the company announced a 25% reduction in its workforce. It also stated it was exiting the United Kingdom, European Union, and Australia markets.
The exchange said it was sharpening its focus on the United States and on prediction markets. Gemini cited the state of the crypto market and the ability of artificial intelligence to enable doing more with less as reasons for the shift. Its prediction platform, Gemini Predictions, launched in December 2025. The company said it had gained more than 10,000 users who traded over $24 million since its launch.
The CFTC and a lawyer for Gemini did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the court's decision. The settlement remains in effect, the $5 million penalty stands, and Gemini continues under the permanent injunction without new fines imposed.





