Trade and Till
Business types

Small business owner warns of closure after tax changes

A Chorley pie shop owner says rising costs and a dividend tax increase may force him to close, putting 37 jobs at risk, and challenges a Treasury minister to visit.

A Chorley pie shop owner says rising costs and a dividend tax increase may force him to close, putting 37 jobs at risk...

Small business owner Paul Bowen says he may be forced to close his doors and let 37 staff go. He cites relentless pressure from inflation, National Insurance, and minimum wage rises, alongside a recent increase in dividend tax.

Paul Bowen, who owns a pie business in Chorley, Lancashire, described the current situation as heartbreaking. Profit margins are now minuscule, he stated. "Imagine me turning round to 37 staff and saying, I'm sorry. We're going to have to close our doors," Bowen said. He argues this is not only his problem but one facing every small business, from plumbers and butchers to construction firms and cleaners.

Minister's stance on tax and employers

Chief Secretary to the Treasury Emma Reynolds defended the government's fiscal approach. A Treasury spokesman said the government is sticking to its manifesto tax commitments while being fiscally disciplined, promising not to increase the rates of income tax, national insurance, VAT, or corporation tax.

In an interview on GB News, Reynolds insisted there was a difference between employers and employees, suggesting employers are 'not working people'. She argued that recent tax changes, which she described as 'two per cent on the income tax bands that are in for property and for savings', did not break a manifesto promise.

Business owner's rebuttal on work and pay

Bowen strongly rejected the minister's characterisation. "It is so insulting to small business owners. I cannot believe she thinks we don't work," he said. He accused Reynolds of not understanding how many company directors are paid, explaining that they often take income via dividends, which have seen a two per cent tax increase.

He said business owners work far beyond standard hours, a commitment so extensive it cannot be captured in a simple contract. Bowen feels business owners are being penalised yet again by government policy.

Political reaction and debate

The dispute has drawn sharp political reactions. Shadow work and pensions minister Helen Whately said, This attitude is why Labour is killing our economy. They don't understand businesses are built by hard graft. By working people.

Reform UK Treasury spokesman Robert Jenrick added, Tell that to the millions of small business owners who employ people. Labour haven't a clue about business.

Dispute over business rates relief

Accounts differ on the issue of business rates support. Emma Reynolds stated the Government had offered business rates relief to tens of thousands of small businesses as part of the Chancellor’s Budget.

However, Paul Bowen countered that he would not qualify for this relief because he operates two stores. He challenged Chief Secretary Reynolds to visit his business in Chorley to see firsthand how government policy is impacting employers. He wants her to witness the reality of the struggle to stay afloat.

Related coverage

More from Business types